Iraq, What's The Answer?

[DannyK]

Nah, I was the first. I just get fed up with the debates sometimes

wewt, I knew I wasn't crazy. suck on that Peter Parka!!!!!!!!:24:

 

[All Else Failed]

In the beginning of the thread they were talking about if they should split Iraq into Sunni and Shiite states. what do you think?

There are problems with that, seeing as how th majority of the oil, and thus power, will be in mainly one region, under one party's control. That would inevitably lead to abuse of power. I think dividing them into ethnic states is a good idea, but the oil problem has to be addressed.

 

[Peter Parka]

wewt, I knew I wasn't crazy. suck on that Peter Parka!!!!!!!!:24:

I really couldn't care less if people are fed up with the debate or not. If you're fed up with it, it's very simple to leave the discussion.

 

[dt3]

I really couldn't care less if people are fed up with the debate or not. If you're fed up with it, it's very simple to leave the discussion.

I did!

 

[BadBoy@TheWheel]

I say no to splitting up the tribes. That just does not seem to work, look at Afghanistan, those bastards are never happy with anything you give them, it's not about land to them, it's not about money with most of them...They really feel like they are fighting for Gods favor, that is a thirst you cannot quench by giving them houses with indoor plumbing.

 

[GraceAbounds]

In the beginning of the thread they were talking about if they should split Iraq into Sunni and Shiite states. what do you think?

I think that we should continue to persevere - stay the course. We should continue to try to stop insurgents, terrorist cells, etc., continue to fight for order to be established so that plans can be made and goals can be set and met. I don't think it is our place to split Iraq up. If they want to create 3 states in Iraq (Sunni, Kurds, Shiite) - that will be up to them. It is imperative for Iraq to succeed in the middle east. If we stick with them through this long difficult journey to order and peace - it can have wonderful implications and possibilities for the whole region.

Most people choose to view everything in a negative light though. Hey - that's what sells advertisement.

 

[DannyK]

I really couldn't care less if people are fed up with the debate or not. If you're fed up with it, it's very simple to leave the discussion.

I was just messin' around with you

 

[All Else Failed]

Damn, you really just sounded like Bush.


@ Grace.

 

[DannyK]

I believe that if you do split them up it will just cause more problems. Can you imagine how crazy it would be on the border of those two countries? And as All Else Failed pointed out one side would inevitably dominate the other. In my mind splitting the country would not end well.

 

[DannyK]

Damn, you really just sounded like Bush.


@ Grace.

I'm curious, what would your plan of action be? I'm not coming after you, I just want to know what your thinking.

 

[dt3]

I'm curious, what would your plan of action be? I'm not coming after you, I just want to know what your thinking.

If I may coin an analogy here, I believe he wants to treat Iraq like a cheap hooker...





Pullout and leave them alone to clean up the mess.

 

[All Else Failed]

I'm curious, what would your plan of action be? I'm not coming after you, I just want to know what your thinking.

I already said, divide the nation into each party's respective area and have a oil union sharing program so not one region gets too powerful.

Then leave.


Probably won't happen though. The entire point of Iraq is to establish a permanent military base in the middle east to act as a springboard.

 

[All Else Failed]

If I may coin an analogy here, I believe he wants to treat Iraq like a cheap hooker...





Immediate withdrawal and leave them alone to clean up the mess.

No, I am a gentleman!

 

[GraceAbounds]

I believe that if you do split them up it will just cause more problems. Can you imagine how crazy it would be on the border of those two countries? And as All Else Failed pointed out one side would inevitably dominate the other. In my mind splitting the country would not end well.

Iraq government could decide to split their country up into 'states'/'regions' - not separate countries. That may help them, it may not - all I'm saying is that it is their choice as to what they do. They are the ones that have to ultimately make it work.

 

[All Else Failed]

i think its rather naive to think that all of the decisions will be up to the Iraqi government alone. We have too much invested in that region to let them do what they want.

 

[BadBoy@TheWheel]

i think its rather naive to think that all of the decisions will be up to the Iraqi government alone. We have too much invested in that region to let them do what they want.

Right now they could not find their own asses with a roadmap and a flashlight anyways. And they stand no hope of providing for themselves with these former big oil flunkies calling the shots.

 

[DannyK]

If I may coin an analogy here, I believe he wants to treat Iraq like a cheap hooker...





Pullout and leave them alone to clean up the mess.

nice.

 

[All Else Failed]

Right now they could not find their own asses with a roadmap and a flashlight anyways. And they stand no hope of providing for themselves with these former big oil flunkies calling the shots.

We seem to not be able to find our asses, either.


The big oil monopolies in the region should be busted up, in order to actually have the government have a chance.

 

[GraceAbounds]

No, I am a gentleman!

:24: :clap Good one AEF!

 

[DannyK]

We seem to not be able to find our asses, either.


The big oil monopolies in the region should be busted up, in order to actually have the government have a chance.

We know exactly what were doing over there, the only problem is resistance.