I have no doubt there are many men who could not choose to be attracted to men to save their life. But perhaps some men can. Similar to food tastes. I could not choose to like lima beans to save my life. I could eat them to save my life but I don't think I would ever like them. But I could perhaps choose to like coffee because I don't dislike it very much now. A friend of mine said she chose to like coffee because it is a social drink. At first she didn't care for it but she learned to like it. However, I think it's safe to say no homosexuals in the USA choose to be gay. Why would they considering all the social stigma attached to it.
I do not know all the psychological studies regarding homosexuality and have no training in the field. So if you (Panacea) tell me I'm all wet here I'll believe you. But, in the mean time, I think the idea of a homosexuality scale is intriguing.
Nah you're totally on the right track, I understand what you mean. Accountable too.
The thing that is so hard for a lot of people to grasp (not meaning or anyone here specifically) is the idea that gender identity and human sexuality can take a lot more forms than just "man", "woman", "straight, "gay". That's why I hear a lot of people going "bisexuality, wtf??" and "wtf is with trannies, are they gay or what??". This culture is so black and white, most of us fit so cleanly into little categories but I don't think that's reality. People hide things and force themselves into lifestyles they may not feel 100% right about.
There is absolutely a continuum for both gender and sexuality. I suspect gender identity is more environmentally influenced (if I'm gay, HOW gay should I be? lol) , while sexuality is more biologically influenced.
I think any combination is possible, theoretically, and closeted gay men who marry women, sleep with them, and later realize straight relationships are not what they prefer are not, in my opinion "choosing to be gay". This is merely semantics, it's not as if I am disagreeing with Accountable at all, but in my opinion they are bisexual individuals, and were born so. It's not so much a choice to go from straight to gay (because they were never straight, they probably fantasized about men all along), but a choice to go with their most dominant preference.
Just one anecdote of course, but when my friend came out, the first thing I asked was "When did you realize? Did you decide?" and he said he just never felt "right". He didn't know exactly what he was feeling, just that he didn't like girls the way other guys did. He dated them, never slept with them (I believe he is truly truly gay; he'd probably vomit violently if he saw a vagina lol) but didn't come out until he was 21.