Did You Serve ?

[Tim]

answer the question

 

[Tim]

Don't be scared, I already know the answer

 

[The Man]

answer the question

Tim you stated I condone torture
Back that claim.
I dont have to answer anything...its your claim

 

[Tim]

 

[The Man]

If that is how we prove things.
I just as well say
Tim condones torture
Tim licks ass.
Tim eats out of a garbage can.
No need to prove it right.

Its people like you that ruin a quality forum.
Often referred to as trolls

 

[Tim]

 

[The Man]

Answer mine..I posted it first.
Show the posts where I condone torture.
You do understand you are being a troll Tim

 

[Tim]

 

[The Man]

It has been answered several times...you said you have read the thread
And here it is again.

by me below
"While it legally may have not been torture at the time....it needs to be illegal now"

Show your proof I condone torture.....perhaps try to build your credibility back up

 

[The Man]

Now stop trolling my thread I am starting to have issue with it.

 

[Tim]

Why don't you answer my direct question TM?
Is it because you do condone it and you'll look stupid admitting it now TM?
We all know your stance on torture TM, you don't need to hide it.
Just answer the question TM?

Admit it, when Bush had those detainees tortured you were all for it. You think it was keeping you safe and it was the right thing to do, didn't you TM?

Just answer the question.

Do you think we were right to water board those detainees?

 

[The Man]

You made the claim I condone torture
Back it.
Its really that simple.

 

[The Man]

So why dont you just point to the posts to support your claim
or are you a punk

 

[Tim]

yes I am a punk


Now answer the question

 

[The Man]

yes I am a punk


Now answer the question

yes I am a punk

I dont associate with punks

While you haven't built your credibility back up...you did gain a little respect for starting to show a little honestly

 

[Tim]

 

[robdawg1]

The water boarding was done under bush policy.
It was legal at the time...therefore there was no argument to legalize torture.
Bush was already gone.

Several hundred detainees at gitmo..3 were boarded that uncovered information to another planned attack.
I have no problem with rational nations...I do have problems with radicals.
Drone em snipe em bomb em...I just dont give a shit...whether the fruitcake is in a parking lot or watching tv..I just dont care.

The option is to set back and do nothing....remember stone this is not conventional...they hide and mix among the population which is what makes it so difficult.
Its not meet on a hill and have at it...if that were the case we could stomp em rather fast.
AQ and the Taliban are not concentrated to one location...And the host nations just havent made any progress on elimination stone ...so either the effort isnt there or they are not capable.
A mix of both actually.

OK TM....that seems to me like a pretty strong argument for water boarding, which is by humanitarian definition , torture. It is a violation of the Geneva Convention, and that is why they wouldn't do it on US soil....


TM, you are starting to get a little hostile, as though you are not capable of rationally debating. You call names and throw accusations....seems as though you are having a bit of trouble keeping it together....you ok?

 

[The Man]

OK TM....that seems to me like a pretty strong argument for water boarding, which is by humanitarian definition , torture. It is a violation of the Geneva Convention, and that is why they wouldn't do it on US soil....


TM, you are starting to get a little hostile, as though you are not capable of rationally debating. You call names and throw accusations....seems as though you are having a bit of trouble keeping it together....you ok?

Let me guess...still being dishonest rob

Here is my position which has been stated several times

While it legally may have not been torture at the time....it needs to be illegal now.

Is there something about that you do not understand?

 

[The Man]

While it legally may have not been torture at the time....it needs to be illegal now.

Is there something about that you do not understand?

 

[robdawg1]

Bitching and moaning to me about 3 guys getting boarded changes nothing...I will not condemn those that legally boarded those three at the time....to do is chickenshit as they were looking out for the welfare of the united states.

Write your congressman if you dont like the way the law was written then...if you are lucky you may get a response back "what do you want us to do about it now"

Let it go man...let it go.

If this isnt condoning torture i dont know what is.....