Obama's Crowning Moment?

Users who are viewing this thread

Peter Parka

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,387
Reaction score
3
Tokenz
0.06z
Couldn't give a shit for myself or anyone else outside the USA but I'll be pleased to see a historic moment for my USA friends to get something which has been a right over here for about 60 years.:clap

Obama hails 'historic' health bid
US President Barack Obama has described a congressional vote on healthcare reform due on Sunday as a "historic" moment in a century-long struggle.
Speaking at a rally in Virginia, he dismissed criticism of the bill from Republicans and some Democrats.
Appealing to lawmakers and citizens to back the legislation, he said: "The time for reform is right now."
Democrats are still working to secure enough House of Representatives votes to pass a Senate version of the bill.
The BBC's Mark Mardell in Virginia says that Mr Obama's speech was fiery but the Democratic Party seems deflated, with no real desire to motivate the people.
'Hard debate'
The reforms would deliver on Mr Obama's top domestic priority by providing insurance to some 30 million Americans who currently lack it.


Not only can we afford to do this. We can't afford not to do this
US President Barack Obama

Calling the battle to create the bill, "messy", "frustrating" and "ugly", Mr Obama said the final proposal was the culmination of a year of "hard debate".
"Every argument has been made," he told students at George Mason University.
"We have incorporated the best ideas from Democrats and Republicans into a final proposal."
The House of Representatives and the Senate adopted different versions of the bill in November and December.
The usual procedure would be for two versions of legislation to be combined into a single bill for President Obama to sign into law. But after Senate Democrats lost the 60-seat majority required to defeat a filibuster by Republicans, Democratic leaders decided to use a controversial procedure to ensure the bill's passage.
Under the plan, the House will vote on a package of reconciliation "fixes" amending the Senate bill.
'Bill of rights'
The Senate will then be able to make changes in a separate bill using a procedure known as reconciliation, which allows budget provisions to be approved with 51 votes - rather than the 60 needed to overcome blocking tactics.

MARDELL'S AMERICA
I can't help thinking the Democrats haven't been trying or even thinking that hard about how to win this argument. The president seems sometimes like a one-man band
Mark Mardell BBC North America editor

Mr Obama brushed aside Republican claims that the bill was too costly and said Americans had been told "a whole bunch of nonsense" about its contents.
The reform, he said, "brings our deficit down by more than one trillion dollars over the next two decades. Not only can we afford to do this. We can't afford not to do this."
According to Congressional Budget Office, the final version of the Democrats' healthcare plan will cut the federal deficit by $138bn over 10 years.
The non-partisan body said the proposed legislation would cost about $940bn over a decade.


ANALYSIS
Paul Adams, BBC News, Washington President Obama's speech to college students in suburban Washington was passionate, loud and frequently unscripted. But the outcome of this long, bitter debate is still not certain. With Republicans united in opposition, at least 28 Democrats in the House of Representatives say they will also oppose the bill. Just another 10 opponents out of about 30 who are currently undeclared, and the bill will not pass.
The Republicans - who seem to sense that they may lose Sunday's historic vote - are already promising to punish vulnerable Democrats in November's mid-term elections.

The president also lashed out an insurance companies whose lobbyists, he said, were prowling the corridors of Washington, trying to prevent the bill passing.
"We are going to end the worst practices of insurance companies. This is a patients' bill of rights on steroids," he told a cheering crowd.
The reforms would increase insurance coverage through tax credits for the middle class and expansion of the Medicaid programme for the poor.
If approved, they would represent the biggest change in the US healthcare system since the creation in the 1960s of Medicare, the government-run scheme for Americans aged 65 or over.




Story from BBC NEWS:
 
  • 91
    Replies
  • 2K
    Views
  • 0
    Participant count
    Participants list

Alien Allen

Froggy the Prick
Messages
16,633
Reaction score
22
Tokenz
1,206.36z
This is no crowning moment

You are dreaming if you think this is national health care

20 million still will be left without

This is just a bull shit proposal that is all about the Obama and democrat legacy

And they will pay dearly for passing this using the bull shit scheme they have concocted

Nothing of this importance has ever passed without bipartisan support

This is the height of arrogance by the left to ignore a public that is against this bull shit

Peter you are speaking on something you are not familiar.
 

Tangerine

Slightly Acidic
Messages
3,679
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
What is being rammed down our throats is not even REMOTELY similar to universal health care of the UK or Canada.

It's nothing more than forcing American's to purchase something from a private company that they may not want or are able to afford. It's completely unconstitutional and I predict it will be fought in the courts for many years, wasting billions more dollars for no good reason.
 

Alien Allen

Froggy the Prick
Messages
16,633
Reaction score
22
Tokenz
1,206.36z
yup there are already states prepared to file complaints in court

Makes you wonder just what kind of idiots are leading the left when they have to know this is headed for such trouble

I would have supported giving everybody medicare before this bullshit

It is all about proving a point for both sides. The left can whine all they want about the right being just a party of no but the left is just as complicit. They are the party of no we will not stop and will resort to doing anything to cram this up everybodys ass.

This tactic is going to set a horrible precedent. I am strongly pro choice and I fear when the right gets in power they will use this to process to ban abortions. If for no other reason the democrats need to be stopped as this is not the way to pass legislation.
 

Peter Parka

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,387
Reaction score
3
Tokenz
0.06z
What is being rammed down our throats is not even REMOTELY similar to universal health care of the UK or Canada.

It's nothing more than forcing American's to purchase something from a private company that they may not want or are able to afford. It's completely unconstitutional and I predict it will be fought in the courts for many years, wasting billions more dollars for no good reason.

Who will be fighting it, thus costing billions of dollars?
 

Accountable

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,962
Reaction score
1
Tokenz
0.00z
Obama himself said this is only the first step toward government takeover of the insurance and medical industries. He said even Canada had a transition step.

As for rights, Peter - a right is not something that places unequal obligation on others. A right is free, such as the right of speech or the right to think or believe what you wish. When one entity takes something from another by force it is theft, whether they give part of the booty to others or not.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Accountable

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,962
Reaction score
1
Tokenz
0.00z
Is it too early for I Told You So? From last January:

If I've said it once, I've said it ... well I've said it. The goal right now is to pass something, anything, that can be called a healthcare bill. As long as they can get the nose under the tent .........

And it's going to work, too. The debate has shifted from "should we?" to "how much is acceptable to the most people?"

Socialists win another round.
 

Dana

In Memoriam - RIP
Messages
42,904
Reaction score
10
Tokenz
0.17z
This is no crowning moment

You are dreaming if you think this is national health care

20 million still will be left without

This is just a bull shit proposal that is all about the Obama and democrat legacy

And they will pay dearly for passing this using the bull shit scheme they have concocted

Nothing of this importance has ever passed without bipartisan support

This is the height of arrogance by the left to ignore a public that is against this bull shit

Peter you are speaking on something you are not familiar.
Exactly... They want to FORCE people to buy health care even if they have a shit job and can't afford it or they'll just up and take it from your pycheck.
 

Tim

Having way too much fun
Valued Contributor
Messages
13,518
Reaction score
43
Tokenz
111.11z
I can only hope and pray that this will lead to universal health care and the death of private primary health insurance.
 

Alien Allen

Froggy the Prick
Messages
16,633
Reaction score
22
Tokenz
1,206.36z
I can only hope and pray that this will lead to universal health care and the death of private primary health insurance.
well duh that is what is supposed to lead to

the govt has a system of forcing us into things we would never agree to

they do it in increments

piss em off only just so much at a time
 

retro

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,886
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
I can only hope and pray that this will lead to universal health care and the death of private primary health insurance.

Which would be a wholly unconstitutional system that will be challenged by the states if they ever try to pass something like that. The way they're trying to pass this legislation to begin with is unconstitutional as far as I'm concerned. They're trying to pass it without even voting on it.

Then if they can force it through with Deem and Pass, they'll start voting on extra additions to the bill. This is the absolute height of arrogance and they're going to pay dearly for it. Like I've said before, the last time Congress passed something as unpopular as this legislation,it was the Kansas-Nebraska act, which directly led to the founding of the Republican party and eventually the Civil War (though there were obviously other factors in the Civil War, but this was a big one). If they pass this, I can almost guarantee you massive GOP victories the likes of which haven't been seen since 1994. I also think that if it gets passed, just about *any* Republican will be able to run against Obama and win.
 

Accountable

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,962
Reaction score
1
Tokenz
0.00z
Which would be a wholly unconstitutional system that will be challenged by the states if they ever try to pass something like that. The way they're trying to pass this legislation to begin with is unconstitutional as far as I'm concerned. They're trying to pass it without even voting on it.

Then if they can force it through with Deem and Pass, they'll start voting on extra additions to the bill. This is the absolute height of arrogance and they're going to pay dearly for it. Like I've said before, the last time Congress passed something as unpopular as this legislation,it was the Kansas-Nebraska act, which directly led to the founding of the Republican party and eventually the Civil War (though there were obviously other factors in the Civil War, but this was a big one). If they pass this, I can almost guarantee you massive GOP victories the likes of which haven't been seen since 1994. I also think that if it gets passed, just about *any* Republican will be able to run against Obama and win.

None of which will matter, because the repubs will no more let go of power gained than the dems will.

Tim, if it's such a great and wonderful thing, why does it have to be wrestled through in secret meetings and with bribes & threats? Isn't it important enough to stand against opposition?
 

Tangerine

Slightly Acidic
Messages
3,679
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
I can only hope and pray that this will lead to universal health care and the death of private primary health insurance.


Forcing millions MORE people onto the rolls of the private for-profit insurance companies is not exactly a great first step in that direction.
 

Tim

Having way too much fun
Valued Contributor
Messages
13,518
Reaction score
43
Tokenz
111.11z
Which would be a wholly unconstitutional system that will be challenged by the states if they ever try to pass something like that. The way they're trying to pass this legislation to begin with is unconstitutional as far as I'm concerned. They're trying to pass it without even voting on it.

Then if they can force it through with Deem and Pass, they'll start voting on extra additions to the bill. This is the absolute height of arrogance and they're going to pay dearly for it. Like I've said before, the last time Congress passed something as unpopular as this legislation,it was the Kansas-Nebraska act, which directly led to the founding of the Republican party and eventually the Civil War (though there were obviously other factors in the Civil War, but this was a big one). If they pass this, I can almost guarantee you massive GOP victories the likes of which haven't been seen since 1994. I also think that if it gets passed, just about *any* Republican will be able to run against Obama and win.

I love how everyone on the right is getting so upset with deem and pass, yet they didn't say word one when their side used it to ram legislation down our throats hundreds of times before. So unless you were screaming about how unconstitutional it was before, I don't even want to hear about it now.
Hell, I don't like that a bill can be passed this way, it's complete and total bullshit IMHO.
If this bill passes, the country isn't going to rise up and start a civil war (well maybe a few beck fans) there isn't going to be a republican takeover come November, or during the next presidential election.
People are going to see that this bill isn't the great evil that the right has painted it as. After a few months it will be business as usual and the majority of people will see the benefits it has brought to them.
And even if, and that's a huge if, the republicans take back the congress next election, they won't repeal this legislation, they won't have the back-bone.

None of which will matter, because the repubs will no more let go of power gained than the dems will.

Tim, if it's such a great and wonderful thing, why does it have to be wrestled through in secret meetings and with bribes & threats? Isn't it important enough to stand against opposition?

Because both sides are sniveling weasels that are bought and paid for by big business. That's why we are getting a shit bill to begin with. Congress isn't looking out for us, they are too far in bed with their masters.

Forcing millions MORE people onto the rolls of the private for-profit insurance companies is not exactly a great first step in that direction.

I agree. It's a real shame we couldn't get real reform through congress. But there is enough good in this bill that maybe, just maybe it will wake enough people up and real change will follow.
 

Tim

Having way too much fun
Valued Contributor
Messages
13,518
Reaction score
43
Tokenz
111.11z
Forcing millions MORE people onto the rolls of the private for-profit insurance companies is not exactly a great first step in that direction.

Don't forget that while they are forcing millions to get insurance, they are also providing people with more options and financial help to get their insurance.

But I don't like the fact that ANY of my tax dollars are going to private for profit insurance.
 

retro

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,886
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
I love how everyone on the right is getting so upset with deem and pass, yet they didn't say word one when their side used it to ram legislation down our throats hundreds of times before. So unless you were screaming about how unconstitutional it was before, I don't even want to hear about it now.
Hell, I don't like that a bill can be passed this way, it's complete and total bullshit IMHO.
If this bill passes, the country isn't going to rise up and start a civil war (well maybe a few beck fans) there isn't going to be a republican takeover come November, or during the next presidential election.
People are going to see that this bill isn't the great evil that the right has painted it as. After a few months it will be business as usual and the majority of people will see the benefits it has brought to them.
And even if, and that's a huge if, the republicans take back the congress next election, they won't repeal this legislation, they won't have the back-bone.

Deem and Pass is bullshit no matter which party uses it... and I'm a Libertarian, and not a member of the "right wing". I laugh at your assertion that the GOP isn't going to have huge gains as a direct result of this legislation.

Your flippant attitude tells me that you're every bit as arrogant as the Democrats in congress that are trying to ram this down out throats.
 

Accountable

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,962
Reaction score
1
Tokenz
0.00z
I love how everyone on the right is getting so upset with deem and pass, yet they didn't say word one when their side used it to ram legislation down our throats hundreds of times before. So unless you were screaming about how unconstitutional it was before, I don't even want to hear about it now.

I hadn't even heard about it till now, or I would've said the same back then. I don't see how it could be constitutional, but that's a foreign word to you and those in Washington nowadays. I can't imagine one good federal law passed since the 60's, but I could easily be wrong.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
78,875Threads
2,185,391Messages
4,959Members
Back
Top