Did You Serve ?

[Stone]

Geeze pete.......30 pages, 439 posts and 1559 views and nothing's changed.....same old shit, TM

Grow up, man-up, or what ever it takes to generate some common sense between your only active 3 brain cells......you posted that shit and it's come back to haunt you.

 

[Alien Allen]

TM I have a question

Maybe this will make it clearer

If Obamas AG determined they could once again waterboard would you support that?

 

[Alien Allen]

and I will state as I am sure as I did at the other site

I don't see how it could be called torture if it is legal

maybe I am wrong but I don't believe a court or a legislature has ruled or made law outlawing it.

until then it I believe would be considered legal.

A technicality but those that know me are aware I thrive on such stuff

 

[The Man]

You knowingly posted a false post Stone

as you read the post below by me and acknowledged it....before you made your accusation.

"While it legally may have not been torture at the time....it needs to be illegal now.".....by me

It is the only exchange before the accusation...it was the only post in regard to the topic.

You have openly made false posts as an attempt to assassinate my character

 

[Stone]

Here is your statement below Stone


Back that statement....or are you a liar...its your choice

Piss off.....you're not a moderator


You've been given the quotes you've made in that regard, once given I don't have to keep repeating your demands.

You're a fuckin' liar, Stone

Shocking, just shocking I tell you :eek

 

[Stone]

You knowingly posted a false post Stone

as you read the post below by me and acknowledged it....before you made your accusation.

"While it legally may have not been torture at the time....it needs to be illegal now.".....by me

It is the only exchange before the accusation...it was the only post in regard to the topic.

You have openly made false posts as an attempt to assassinate my character

 

[The Man]

and I will state as I am sure as I did at the other site

I don't see how it could be called torture if it is legal

maybe I am wrong but I don't believe a court or a legislature has ruled or made law outlawing it.

until then it I believe would be considered legal.

A technicality but those that know me are aware I thrive on such stuff

It was legal at the time...and wasnt deemed torture...that has probably changed now.

Therefore I dont want to prosecute those that performed the boarding.

According to the lefts here...that makes me an advocator .

How can I support bringing about charges on someone and punishing them when it was legal.

I cant as that would be an actual crime itself...and actually be torture by legal definition...by false arrest and punishment

 

[Stone]

.................

I don't see how it could be called torture if it is legal

...................................

If Adolf Hitler was alive, you could use him as a reference.
Or how about Pol Pot?
Joe Stalin?


Yeah.....makes a difference whose doing it, eh?

 

[Stone]

It was legal at the time...and wasnt deemed torture...that has probably changed now.

Therefore I dont want to prosecute those that performed the boarding.

According to the lefts here...that makes me an advocator .

How can I support bringing about charges on someone and punishing them when it was legal.

I cant as that would be an actual crime itself...and actually be torture by legal definition.

And logic takes a time out to go into catywompass mode

 

[The Man]

TM I have a question

Maybe this will make it clearer

If Obamas AG determined they could once again waterboard would you support that?

If they could legally water board then I cant condemn those that are doing their job....I dont advocate the idea..but I cant condemn it and insist charges be brought about on something that would be legal

 

[The Man]

If Adolf Hitler was alive, you could use him as a reference.
Or how about Pol Pot?
Joe Stalin?


Yeah.....makes a difference whose doing it, eh?

You dont get to determine what is torture by law.,,,you are not the law.

 

[Stone]

If they could legally water board then I cant condemn those that are doing their job....I dont advocate the idea..but I cant condemn it and insist charges be brought about on something that would be legal

Looks like you again shot yourself in the foot.

but I cant condemn it

Pro torture ..............

 

[The Man]

And logic takes a time out to go into catywompass mode

Its actually rather simple.
Its why we have laws...so they are to be followed
You can not use the law according to how you think it should be written

 

[Stone]

You dont get to determine what is torture by law.,,,you are not the law.

Nimrod.....you've just been claiming torture could be made legal....

 

[The Man]

Looks like you again shot yourself in the foot.






Pro torture ..............

How can I condemn those that are doing their job?

Am I supposed to condemn those that give the juice in a death penalty case?

With your logic that would be yes

 

[Stone]

Its actually rather simple.
Its why we have laws...so they are to be followed
You can not use the law according to how you think it should be written

Back to catywompass logic again I see......the comment is irrelevant to the discussion of you being pro torture.

 

[Stone]

How can I condemn those that are doing their job?

Am I supposed to condemn those that give the juice in a death penalty case?

With your logic that would be yes

Joe Stalin would have loved you in his ranks....

 

[Stone]

TM....you do realize this line of thought isn't favoring your position?

 

[The Man]

Back to catywompass logic again I see......the comment is irrelevant to the discussion of you being pro torture.

If you dont like the laws,,,that your problem.
I do not support condemning those that water boarded those three as they were doing their job according to law
If you want to go track em down and hang em by the nuts then go ahead.
All your fucking bitching and moaning does nothing....I didnt make the laws.

I am not trying to sound brash but there is no other way to put it

 

[Stone]

This thread is getting a lot of views, TM........how's you confidence these days?