The OFFICIAL American Idol thread

Users who are viewing this thread

Tegan

Member
Messages
446
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
IDOL PEOPLE...grrr i know yall arte out there!

what do yall think of melinda going home?!?! i was shocked..but in a way not so...she was the best, but the least marketable. Idol has become a popularity contest!

It's always been a popularity contest. Any time you base the outcome of a contest on viewer voting, it's a popularity contest and has no real musical credibility, period. At least on Rock Star Super Nova the band actually chose the winners (even if they chose wrong :p). Letting America vote on the best singer was a stupid idea from the get go. Some of the most listened to "artists" in this country can't hold a tune in a bucket.
 
  • 125
    Replies
  • 6K
    Views
  • 0
    Participant count
    Participants list

Charmer

Active Member
Messages
2,409
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
IDOL PEOPLE...grrr i know yall arte out there!

what do yall think of melinda going home?!?! i was shocked..but in a way not so...she was the best, but the least marketable. Idol has become a popularity contest!


You hit it right on the head, Clare. The key word being "marketable."

To be honest, her looks are not model/celebrity-type camera-friendly. So, it does somewhat turn into a popularity contest, the person being not only a good singer, but "easy" on the eyes to a young audience.

But Melinda did and does have the best voice....

I wanted Melinda to win from the start until about 5 weeks ago and then I wanted Jordin to win. Unfortunately, it looks like Blake might win according to polls and blogs, but Jordin to me has a more versatile voice and would be easily marketable.

**And now let me go hide my face because people are talking about me for posting too long of a post about a reality TV show!
icon11.gif
 

Boomer

Nipples-O-Steel
Messages
15,168
Reaction score
7
Tokenz
0.01z
*peeks in*


I hate to be a troll, but....*looks around cautiously* THIS SHOW SUX!!!

*Runs out of the thread laughing like a mad man.*
 
Messages
414
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
This is one show I just don't get!

I've tried to watch it, given the amount of media hype it gets I had to give it a go.
I found it to be pretty boring. I suppose if you really love that style of music it may be more interesting. (IE: mainstream, mediocre pop crap that the radio stations shove down your throat anyway.)
I've always been a bit eclectic with my music and I don't think there's enough of a variety there.
Besides, the judges drive me mad. Simon is a flat out prick. Paula is a drunk or something....who really knows what she's on? And Randy? Had anyone even heard of him prior to this show? And he's a bit of a self imposed stereotype. "I'm feelin' ya dawg" Just sounds ludicrous coming from a middle aged man.

I do find the very first few days funny. The auditions phase. Just who in the hail told some of those people they had talent? And why, oh why would they go on National TV and make complete and utter fools of themselves?
It's a bit like a train wreck, you just have to look!
 

SRC

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,251
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
the girl with all the glitter on her face singing Janice Joplin or whatever it was .. and the way she exploded after .. was good freaking stuff.
 

Mrs Behavin

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,411
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.55z
I wont get to watch as much of it this year as ususal because of my work schedule :( Sucks cause I am so addicted to that show
 
78,874Threads
2,185,388Messages
4,959Members
Back
Top