The Best QB...

[TheOriginalJames]

Out of the 32 starters, and the 32+ back up QBs in the league, who is the absolute best?

Why do you think this?


Personally I'll throw this out there, I don't think it's Manning.

My personal view is Tony Romo is above Tom Brady, but Brady is nipping at his heals.

 

[TheOriginalJames]

Romo's rating may be lower overall, but in single games Romo will put up numbers like 143.x ratings. Simply impressive.

 

[Haus]

i dunno. Tom brady is awesome. took over for drew bledsoe and led the Pats to 3 superbowls.

in years and years down the road he'll be up there with the likes of great quarterbacks of the past if he stays healthy. like Young, marino, montana, favre, elway. not a fluke like kurt warner

IMO of course

 

[Haus]

im not a Pats fan but you cant deny his ability

 

[TheOriginalJames]

Of course not. I'm taking a completely non-biased point of view on this topic.

 

[NightWarrior]

I hate to say it, but Brady is the best of the crop. He rarely, if ever, chokes in the big games. His play today should speak volumes, playing in an unfriendly, loud environment, plus he plays well in NE winters. In 2007, I'd take him over Romo for this alone, Romo hasn't proven to win the big game yet. But give him time, he will get there, no doubt.

I also can't rule out Brett Favre. When he is on and has a supporting cast, he is one heck of a QB.

 

[dt3]

i dunno. Tom brady is awesome. took over for drew bledsoe and led the Pats to 3 superbowls.

in years and years down the road he'll be up there with the likes of great quarterbacks of the past if he stays healthy. like Young, marino, montana, favre, elway. not a fluke like kurt warner

IMO of course

If he retired today, he'd still be up there with those guys. I say Brady hands down.

On a side note this dumbass I work with (he's also a Colts fan), who always tries to act like he knows football said "Ya know, I think Favre's a first ballot Hall of Famer." I was like "Gee, ya fuckin think?"

 

[TheOriginalJames]

^ :24:

 

[dt3]

^ :24:

This dumbass also tried to convince me that the last few years, the Colts and Pats have played twice in the REGULAR SEASON every year. He wouldn't believe me when I told him that was only possible if they were in the same division, so I made him look it up. He never admitted he was wrong.

 

[AUDRAA]

Im going with Brady and my boy Favre

 

[NightWarrior]

Im going with Brady and my boy Favre

You better say who I say!

 

[AUDRAA]

or what??

 

[NightWarrior]

You know what

 

[Maulds]

I'm gonna say Jon Kitna is just ahead of Neil O'Donnell, Vinny Testaverde and Ryan Leaf

 

[UncleBacon]

I think Brady is...he done so much wioth so little....he's made all stars out of no bodies....and won 3 superbowls with them....and now that he has receivers to throw to....he's having an amazing year

 

[NightWarrior]

It does make things easier when you can just throw up the ball to Moss because he will catch it. He made Daunte look like a friggin rock star in Minnesota.

 

[Boomer]

My votes on Peyton. The man can scramble and his throwing speed and accuracy is great.

 

[sundvlfn88]

Tough ? I would have to say Brady, but I do like Manning. I also like Favre for his desire.