Without all doubt, gays should be treated with the same rights as straight people. Just like black is treated just as well as white, disabled as not, gay people shouldn't be excluded from the peoples' rights for being different. Personally, I don't care if it was a choice or what they were born with, it's still what they claim to be. Does anybody have a right to judge that? No. As for the Catholics that are against them getting married, I respect your decision. I have my opinion, you have yours (not saying all of them believe this, but the truth is that some do), so I agree equivalent trade is in order. But just like you think marriage between homosexuals is wrong, I believe that you resorting to malevolent protest is wrong. It's not what God would have done and is absolutely NOT what his son died for. Given any of you are Catholic/Christian and beating innocent people down in the ways I just explained, you are no pure child of Him in my eyes, nor a proper follower of Him. Just someone that thinks religion is all a mindless cult. Again, this is just directed at the people that will give into violence to rid of gays and lesbians, not those who simply disagree with it. Please forgive me if I sound biased, as I am a lesbian myself. But really, I've supported gay marriage since God-knows-when, but I'll tell you, well before I figured out my sexuality.
Just my [rather long] two cents.