Need opinions

[HottyToddyChick]

I am crocheting a scarf for a friend who has been trying to get it done for four years now, and I'm getting near the end.

He gave me some room for doing what I think works best, and I'm struggling because I feel like he has something in mind but doesn't know how to express it.

I'm doing large sections of grey and navy, alternating. He wants fringe on the end and all I've been told is to make a LOT of fringe.

I don't know whether to end with two greys or a grey and a navy. And then do I use both colors in the fringe? Or if I end with two greys, should I just do navy fringe? I asked him, and got a non-answer answer... sigh.

I found a few pics that have some of the ideas. Can y'all let me know which one(s) you like most?

Ends on alternating colors, with opposite color fringe:

Ends on same color with alternating fringe:





Ends on same color with opposite fringe:



Or something like this with mixed fringe:

... in which case, end on same color, or alternating?



I think I like the same color with opposite fringe, but I just can't commit

 

[Natasha]

I can only see the first and last picture, so I can't really help. I would do both colors for the fringe, though.

 

[Jezzebelle]

If he asked for lots of fringe, then I like #2

 

[BadBoy@TheWheel]

I don't know, but when you're done with that.....go make dinner woman











:24::24:

 

[acctnt shan]

I like alternating fringe.

 

[BadBoy@TheWheel]

I like alternating fringe.

Lunatic fringe rules!!!.....wait...

 

[HottyToddyChick]

I don't know, but when you're done with that.....go make dinner woman






:24::24:

Damn you're bossy!

I think number two it is. That way its blended better and not so blunt.

 

[croninashley]

My favorite one is number 2

 

[MindyT]

My favorite is picture #2. It looks fuller and warmer! That's just my opinion.

 

[griz bear]

I like #2 too

 

[phatboi]

A medium-ish length alternating colour fringe would look really nice in my opinion