Hypothetical battle

[retro]

Gandalf the White



vs.

Dumbledore



vs.

Obi-Wan Kenobi




Who wins and why?

 

[Brujahpriest]

Gandolf the White: while the other two went peacefully Gandalf was "reborn" from Gandalf the Grey after he went down fighting a demon.

 

[freakofnature]

 

[cam elle toe]

Gandolf the White: while the other two went peacefully Gandalf was "reborn" from Gandalf the Grey after he went down fighting a demon.

This...plus..I like him the best and he has Shadowfax

 

[alice in chains]

what a bunch of nerds!

 

[HK]

Fuck that's hard.


Personally, I think Obi Wan would be out pretty quickly. Compared to a pair of wizards, I don't think he'd stand much of a chance, and I can imagine the other two might even take him out together first, so that they could have it out without the Jedi distraction


After that, I want to say Dumbledore would win, I really do, because I've always preferred him, but I imagine Gandalf as somewhat less susceptible to age, and like Brujah points out, Gandalf has actually come back from the dead once, whereas Dumbledore has only appeared as a ghost, which says something about the lifeforce Gandalf is obviously wielding.

 

[pjbleek]

Fuck that's hard.


Personally, I think Obi Wan would be out pretty quickly. Compared to a pair of wizards, I don't think he'd stand much of a chance, and I can imagine the other two might even take him out together first, so that they could have it out without the Jedi distraction


After that, I want to say Dumbledore would win, I really do, because I've always preferred him, but I imagine Gandalf as somewhat less susceptible to age, and like Brujah points out, Gandalf has actually come back from the dead once, whereas Dumbledore has only appeared as a ghost, which says something about the lifeforce Gandalf is obviously wielding.

use the force, or you going to get yer ass kicked....or bring in Link from the Zelda days and we'll see

 

[KLD1019]

Gandolf the White: while the other two went peacefully Gandalf was "reborn" from Gandalf the Grey after he went down fighting a demon.

definitely agree! (despite the fact ive only watched LOTR and none of star wars or HP)

 

[darkcgi]

Im torn
I'm gonna say Gandolf lets face it it mideval times and he was thrown around like a sack of potatoes and came back magic and strength
obi wan hes got the force and the sabor uh and thats it
dombledore he's keen and beyond but I dont see him swinging blades

 

[darkcgi]

im a nerd hes a nerd wouldnt you like to be a nerd too

 

[anathelia]

I thought about it, and I say Dumbledore.

Gandalf didn't do too well when he fought another wizard.

 

[Zorak]

Considering one defeated a fucking balrog, and the other two are complete ponces and spend their time grooming pre-pubescants/Mark Hamill... that's an easy one

 

[satinbutterfly]

Gandalf the White all the way. I think I'm a little biased though because I just had a LOTR marathon this past weekend.

 

[AUFred]

Gandalf is even a cool name.

 

[Brujahpriest]

Gandalf the White all the way. I think I'm a little biased though because I just had a LOTR marathon this past weekend.

I need to do that soon myself.. with that and a couple other series

 

[freakofnature]

I pondered it and I think that about sums it up.