Calls for change on baby abandonment law

Users who are viewing this thread

Abcinthia

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,469
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.04z
A woman who was abandoned at birth is campaigning to drop the law that allows the prosecution of mothers.

Alley Lofthouse, from Wawne in East Yorkshire, was abandoned when she was just a few hours old.

She is now campaigning for a change in the law which can lead to parents who abandon babies facing prosecution and up to five years imprisonment.

Ms Lofthouse has set up a website to provide information for foundling children and their parents.

She said she was inspired by her own experiences of being adopted as an abandoned baby.

She said: "Every time I speak to one of the family and I find out new information that I can go for, that I can look for.

"So, I thought if we set up this website at least it is a point for foundlings to go to. It's a point maybe even for natural parents to go."


Under a law dating from 1861 people who abandon a child under the age of two can face up to five years in prison. In reality the Crown Prosecution Service seldom brings court actions.

However, Ms Lofthouse said that not having a legal way to abandon an unwanted child can lead to tragedy, citing the case of a Lincolnshire baby that died in 2009 after being left at a Skegness recycling centre.

She hopes to change the law and introduce "baby hatches", found in much of Europe and Asia, which allow mothers to deposit their child anonymously and safely at a hospital.

Claudine Clucas said there was little research on the benefits of baby hatches, as used in South Africa

She claims the change would allow mothers to access health care without any consequences.

"They can go on then to get the help they need. They can then possibly go on to get medical help without fear of prosecution, without fear of being known." she said.

Claudine Clucas, a psychologist at University College London, has researched the issue and believes English attitudes on child abandonment differ from many other countries.

"It is true that over here there is much more anger and blame towards mothers who abandon their babies," she said.

"The reaction in other countries is perhaps more accommodating of the abandonment."

She said that changing the law could be beneficial, as many children are abandoned away from the safety of a hospital.

However, there was little research on whether the use of baby hatches has a beneficial effect on the health of mothers and babies, she added.

"It is difficult to tell whether having procedures in place and laws to make sure there is no harm to the mother would result in better outcomes," said Ms Clucas.

"It is quite controversial at this stage."
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-humber-13697166

The wikipedia page for if anyone doesn't understand baby hatches: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_hatch

There is an epetition as well http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/petitions/18026See


I find it utterly heartbreaking and terribly sad that it is even being talked about, but I do think it's a good idea.

I think most mothers who abandon their children must be in a pretty desperate situation. But having somewhere to drop a baby off that is safe, where the baby will get care straight away is a much better option than babies being abandoned in other places where they might die. True, babies may still be left in other places because the mother doesn't want to use the baby hatch for whatever reason but I think think if it saves one child being left outside to possibly die then its a good thing.
 
  • 4
    Replies
  • 386
    Views
  • 0
    Participant count
    Participants list

Panacea

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,445
Reaction score
3
Tokenz
0.01z
I think most mothers who abandon their children must be in a pretty desperate situation. But having somewhere to drop a baby off that is safe, where the baby will get care straight away is a much better option than babies being abandoned in other places where they might die. True, babies may still be left in other places because the mother doesn't want to use the baby hatch for whatever reason but I think think if it saves one child being left outside to possibly die then its a good thing.

I agree. It should be made as easy as possible for a person to place a baby somewhere safe. That's the main priority to me. If I'm not mistaken, there are places in the US that allow this sort of thing, but I don't know the details.
 

Abcinthia

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,469
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.04z
I agree. It should be made as easy as possible for a person to place a baby somewhere safe. That's the main priority to me. If I'm not mistaken, there are places in the US that allow this sort of thing, but I don't know the details.

According to the Wikipedia page, some US states have a "safe haven" type places (eg hospitals and fire stations) where babies (and sometimes children) can be left anonymously.

We don't really have places like that in the UK because of the law prosecuting people who abandon children. Sometimes babies are left outside hospital but more often you hear about babies in parks, in shop toilets etc.
 

porterjack

Valued Contributor
Valued Contributor
Messages
10,935
Reaction score
305
Tokenz
0.11z
I can see how some might rail against this by saying that taking away the criminal act we as a society would be seen to be endorsing abandonment

( in a way the same argument is used when safe injection sites are offered to heroin addicts we are supposedly condoning their addiction), i just think the health and welfare of the baby and the mother are paramount and if a scared teen mum knows up front that she has a safer alternative then we should pursue this
 

Joe the meek

Active Member
Messages
3,989
Reaction score
67
Tokenz
0.07z
According to the Wikipedia page, some US states have a "safe haven" type places (eg hospitals and fire stations) where babies (and sometimes children) can be left anonymously.

We don't really have places like that in the UK because of the law prosecuting people who abandon children. Sometimes babies are left outside hospital but more often you hear about babies in parks, in shop toilets etc.

Actually, I believe it was either Nebraska or Oklahoma where someone took their teen to drop off under a law that allowed them to.
 
80,547Threads
2,194,834Messages
5,015Members
Back
Top