Who's the greatest QB of all time?

[Mrs Behavin]

My husband was watching ESPN the other night and the question came up whether or not Tom Brady could be the greatest QB ever.
Who do you think is the greatest QB of all time?

 

[Haus]

randall cunningham bar none

the man can Run, throw, Jump, Fly, kick. the man can do it all. Ashame he never got a ring

 

[TheOriginalJames]

Joe Montana

 

[juggler]

Dan Marino:24:

 

[dt3]

Brady, much as I hate to say it.

 

[GuesSAngel]

what about troy aikman?

 

[dt3]

what about troy aikman?

Very very good, but not Top 5 IMO...

 

[UncleBacon]

terry bradshaw/dan marino/joe montana/peyton manning/tom brady/jim kelly/steve young

were and are all great quarterbacks


bret favre too but not as great

 

[Tim]

Favre.


No question.

 

[Haus]

terry bradshaw/dan marino/joe montana/peyton manning/tom brady/jim kelly/steve young

were and are all great quarterbacks


bret favre too but not as great

no john elway??

 

[UncleBacon]

I never really cared for elway....not saying he was bad...he was good...I just think the ones I listed were and are the best

 

[dt3]

terry bradshaw/dan marino/joe montana/peyton manning/tom brady/jim kelly/steve young

were and are all great quarterbacks


bret favre too but not as great

Forgot Johnny U and Joe Willie Namath.

 

[UncleBacon]

Forgot Johnny U and Joe Willie Namath.

I always thought they were both way over rated

 

[dt3]

I never really cared for elway....not saying he was bad...he was good...I just think the ones I listed were and are the best

3rd all-time in yardage and 5th in touchdowns. Gotta put him on the list...

 

[dt3]

I always thought they were both way over rated

I'll agree Namath is pretty overrated, he was more about the hype.

But Unitas was the man. 10 Pro Bowls, 3 MVP's, threw a TD in 47 straight games. And the fact that he played in an era where the rules were heavily tilted against passing the ball and teams ran 40 times a game.

 

[UncleBacon]

I'll agree Namath is pretty overrated, he was more about the hype.

But Unitas was the man. 10 Pro Bowls, 3 MVP's, threw a TD in 47 straight games. And the fact that he played in an era where the rules were heavily tilted against passing the ball and teams ran 40 times a game.

exactly he passed when running was the way to go so people didn't know what to do to stop him...

 

[dt3]

exactly he passed when running was the way to go so people didn't know what to do to stop him...

So what you're saying is he led an innovative offense that changed the game as we know it. That's exactly why I put him on the list

 

[skyblue]

montana........if marino hadn't been injury prone it might have been him

 

[Elle]

Favre.


No question.

 

[Pudding Time]

Gotta take into account the teams they played with. Like Brady, he has one of the most gifted WR's (Moss) to ever play the game.

And with that, I'd say Brett Farve.