Is this why God created sin and evil?

Users who are viewing this thread

Greatest I am

Active Member
Messages
2,030
Reaction score
2
Tokenz
0.09z
Is this why God created sin and evil?
New Jerusalem
2 Peter 3.9
The Lord is not being slow in carrying out his promises, as some people think he is; rather is he being patient with you, wanting nobody to be lost and everybody to be brought to repentance.
2 Peter 3:9 KJ
The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance.
God wanting no one to be lost makes sense to me. After all, He loves us.
If God's will is supreme, and it is, then if He is not wanting any of us to be lost, you can bet your hat that none are lost.
I must conclude then that none are lost as God's will cannot be thwarted.
If none are lost, thanks to God not wanting to lose any of us, then that would eliminate the need for an everlasting hell.
An everlasting hell would be an immoral place by any measure anyway so this view of God not creating a hell seems right.
If we are all to repent then obviously we must all sin or do evil in some form or other.
God facilitates sin by giving us a sinning nature. We cannot fight our God given natures so sin comes rather easily to us. We all sin by nature. If God wanted sinless people then obviously He would create sinless natures. He does not.
It seems natural to me that God, who began, so to speak, as master of all the universe, would not create a hell where He is not master. That would be back sliding and is of course impossible for God. In the beginning God's continence was without blemish. To think that He would allow Himself to end, so to speak, with a black blemish on His white continence would be rather droll.
Is this why God gave us the gifts of sin and evil?
Is this what makes sin and evil part of God's perfect works?
Is this why in the garden of Eden, God said that things were good, even though Satan or the talking snake were there.
Was Satan, always under God's control, acting as a loyal opposition to make sure that Eve ate of the tree of knowledge that gives us our moral sense?
I admit that my view that a hell would be immoral leads me to read the above quote rather literally while knowing that the Vatican and Pope tell us not to take scripture literally even as I know that many do.
God only creates good and perfect works.
Does that make sin and evil good, within the larger picture of perfection?
I think that from His POV it must be so and by trying to look at things from that view, I can glimpse a view of the perfection that we live in even as I can see sin and evil with us.
Rather strange then that we should be thanking God for evil and sin.
Stranger still to think that God wants us to sin to insure that we do His will by repenting for them.


Thoughts.

Regards
DL
 
  • 11
    Replies
  • 355
    Views
  • 0
    Participant count
    Participants list

ColicKillswitch

New Member
Messages
35
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.00z
I like to think of life as a test. God gave us a will to do whatever we want and with that we can choose to follow in his ways or to indulge in the earthly pleasures of sin. What we choose determines how we spend the rest of eternity in the after-life.

The part about God not ruling the underworld caught my eye though. I think that he does rule hell as well as heaven because he chooses who is sent where, satan does not have a say in who goes to his "home." God might not wants anything to do with the place but as far as creating it and controlling the population (lol) goes I think that he does.
 

Greatest I am

Active Member
Messages
2,030
Reaction score
2
Tokenz
0.09z
I like to think of life as a test. God gave us a will to do whatever we want and with that we can choose to follow in his ways or to indulge in the earthly pleasures of sin. What we choose determines how we spend the rest of eternity in the after-life.

The part about God not ruling the underworld caught my eye though. I think that he does rule hell as well as heaven because he chooses who is sent where, satan does not have a say in who goes to his "home." God might not wants anything to do with the place but as far as creating it and controlling the population (lol) goes I think that he does.

Oh no.
Not a literalist reader of scripture.

God, if I can use an analogy, began with a pure white countenance as it applies to Him and all of what He was and created.

You would have Him suffer a blight or black spot, if you will, on His pure white self.

White by itself is perfect.

Just when in God's time line do you see Him placing this black spot on His otherwise perfectly white countenance.

Where did He put it?

On His nose perhaps?

A hell is demonstrably an immoral construct and not something God would create.

Think again for the first time.

Regards
DL
 

Minor Axis

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,294
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.02z
Your in OZ talking to the great wizard and wondering what's going on beyond the curtain? :)

Seriously? Good and evil exists within us. We decide how to act on our impulses. Some of us are truly good and some truly evil and most of us are somewhere in between. You can believe that a dude named God created these things and placed them in us to test us. Or you can believe that the testing of "morality" is a natural byproduct of the intelligent, free-will package. Where we given this package on purpose or by chance? That is unknown.

If there is a proactive God, I think free-form development is a much more plausible choice versus controlling everything, because if everything is controlled, then there really is no free will, there is no way to test us, or allow us to learn and gain wisdom based on our own merits.
 

Greatest I am

Active Member
Messages
2,030
Reaction score
2
Tokenz
0.09z
Your in OZ talking to the great wizard and wondering what's going on beyond the curtain? :)

Seriously? Good and evil exists within us. We decide how to act on our impulses. Some of us are truly good and some truly evil and most of us are somewhere in between. You can believe that a dude named God created these things and placed them in us to test us. Or you can believe that the testing of "morality" is a natural byproduct of the intelligent, free-will package. Where we given this package on purpose or by chance? That is unknown.

Deist is perhaps my closest label so I give nature the credit.

If there is a proactive God, I think free-form development is a much more plausible choice versus controlling everything, because if everything is controlled, then there really is no free will, there is no way to test us, or allow us to learn and gain wisdom based on our own merits.

You are right in the sense that there is a test going on.

You are the student. As I was.

I decided to hand in my paper and was rewarded.

I hope that all of us at some point do so.

Regards
DL
 
78,875Threads
2,185,391Messages
4,959Members
Back
Top