Is Meritocracy a Lie?

[Urvashi]

Western societies claim to be meritocratic, rewarding those who work the hardest. But are success and social mobility truly based on merit, or do systemic advantages play a bigger role? Do you believe anyone can rise to the top with enough effort?

 

[Nomad]

Meritocracy is not a lie. A lot of people are rich and famous reached their position because the were best on what they were doing. However, it is also true that when people have power, they also practice nepotism.

 

[Deep]

Western societies claim to be meritocratic, rewarding those who work the hardest. But are success and social mobility truly based on merit, or do systemic advantages play a bigger role? Do you believe anyone can rise to the top with enough effort?

Hard work matters, but systemic advantages often shape success. Merit alone isn’t enough; opportunity, privilege, and luck also play significant roles.

 

[Urvashi]

Hard work matters, but systemic advantages often shape success. Merit alone isn’t enough; opportunity, privilege, and luck also play significant roles.

Absolutely, while hard work is important, it's not always a level playing field. Access to quality education, supportive networks, timing, and even where you're born can drastically influence outcomes. Success is often a mix of effort and circumstance.

Do you think society should do more to balance these systemic gaps?