Is Cloning/ Genetic Engineering Ethical?

Users who are viewing this thread

Minor Axis

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,294
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.02z
What do you guys and gals think about cloning in general? Good, bad, an abomination? It looks like lots of cloned animals are starting to roll off the assembly line.

I really don't have much problem with cloning animals, but I do recognize that if you go overboard with it, that it would not be sustainable, and it would lead to common weaknesses in the clones. Kind of like every farmer using the same variety of seed for planting up his crops. When a blight comes along, all of those fields with the same variation of seed would be susceptible.

What about cloning people? You know it's going to happen and it's a lot more complicated of a moral issue. I do see it happening, but I don't see bunches of people wanting to have exact replicas of themselves running around. But what I do see happening is genetic engineering as a given because it will remove genetic weaknesses to certain illnesses, and give people designer kids to some degree, but I also realize most people will want kids that look related to them, so I see limits there too.

What about the religious implications? A human clone should have just as much of a soul as a real person although it's unprovable. You can argue that all though that person was not created in the "traditional manner", he/she was still created using the same building blocks of life, which could be argued are God's basic building blocks of life, yes?
 
  • 8
    Replies
  • 216
    Views
  • 0
    Participant count
    Participants list

ssl

Banned
Messages
4,095
Reaction score
1
Tokenz
0.00z
Well, cloning to my knowledge only can occur at the early onset of birth; insomuch as creating a carbon copy at birth with the same DNA does not necessarily mean that the resulting pair will be identical in 20 years. They will not occupy the same space-time dimensions, thereby their environments are different; such differences may not impact the totality of the clone, but will result in different ideals or ideologies held by the two individuals, if cloning a human.

If it were possible to clone the human as they exist at middle or later stages of life, then you would get a more exact copy, including a majority if not all memories and such -- that is where the moral implications would arise; not to mention, the actions taken may implicate the other, resulting a major confusion during a crime investigation.

I would not like to see cloning, based on a few points above, among others; however restricting the progress of technology is also something I am not fond of. Genetic engineering is a different story; I would just ban it altogether.
 

Minor Axis

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,294
Reaction score
0
Tokenz
0.02z
Well, cloning to my knowledge only can occur at the early onset of birth; insomuch as creating a carbon copy at birth with the same DNA does not necessarily mean that the resulting pair will be identical in 20 years. They will not occupy the same space-time dimensions, thereby their environments are different; such differences may not impact the totality of the clone, but will result in different ideals or ideologies held by the two individuals, if cloning a human.

If it were possible to clone the human as they exist at middle or later stages of life, then you would get a more exact copy, including a majority if not all memories and such -- that is where the moral implications would arise; not to mention, the actions taken may implicate the other, resulting a major confusion during a crime investigation.

I would not like to see cloning, based on a few points above, among others; however restricting the progress of technology is also something I am not fond of. Genetic engineering is a different story; I would just ban it altogether.

I believe they have figured out how to take any cell and push it to create a clone. It does not have to be a stem cell from a fetus. Genetic engineering has been done for centuries through selective breeding. It's just that now, its become more powerful. Like creating pigs with high levels of omega 3 making their meat healthier for consumption.

President Bush Speak:
"There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again." —Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 17, 2002
 
78,875Threads
2,185,391Messages
4,959Members
Back
Top