Charlie And The Chocolate Factory (2005)

[Dana]

Some movies should stay classic. I switched over to check it out... They totally fucked this movie up. Toothpaste factory? A Mr. Bucket? There was never a boy who hated chocolate... Is it true the director never even watched the original before making this remake?

 

[Jersey]

Re: Charlie And The Chocolate Family (2005)

the Chocolate Family??

 

[Dana]

Re: Charlie And The Chocolate Family (2005)

the Chocolate Family??

I'm sorry I mean't factory.. It happened to be on ABC Family... I got distracted.

 

[Peter Parka]

Are we talking the one with Johnny Depp? I actually thought it was one of the few re-makes that was better that the original!

 

[Dana]

Yeh the one with Johnny Deep

 

[MMMMatilde]

The new movie was more along the lines of the story by Roald Dahl but the old one was better set out..

I prefer the music in the old version and everyone remembers it..

I like the new version to, I find it to be really well done but not as well created as the old..

I like both and wouldn't be able to pick a favourite from the two..

 

[Peter Parka]

Yeah, I like that the new one is closer to the book. Johnny Depp also gives it that darker edge which Roald Dahl's books were like.

 

[NicAuf]

Gene Wilder's Wonka >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Depp's Wonka

 

[boxer810]

I prefer the new one...Johnny Depp gives much more than Gene Wilder did. And I agree that Johnny Depp's Mr. Wonka was a little darker, which was how he was portrayed in the book. I loved the new movie.

 

[satinbutterfly]

I liked it... but it creeps me out a bit.

 

[Trance97]

I thought the first one creeped me out. lol

 

[BreakfastSurreal]

Are we talking the one with Johnny Depp? I actually thought it was one of the few re-makes that was better that the original!

you've got to be joking!!!! the remake was soooo shitty! I was very disappointed..the WORST part was the fucking music...GAG ME!