American Idol 2011
- Thread starter Veronica
- Start date
Users who are viewing this thread
-
37Replies
-
2KViews
-
0Participant count
-
Participants list
HottyToddyChick
Toes in the water...
I've seen a couple. I'd start rooting for someone, then the next person was better, over and over again.
There's one I really liked though, some girl. I think she was in her teens.
There's one I really liked though, some girl. I think she was in her teens.
He is good. That is who Zach is rooting for (casey i believe is his name
I think your talking about lauren.. blonde hair?
I'm watching. I like Lauren and James too - and Scotty. I know I'm in the minority here, but I'm glad Pia is gone. She bothered me. And it bothered me even more how the judges showed their blatant favoritism for her when she got voted off - make the other contestants feel bad much?
Casey Abrams. He was great in the auditions...hasn't lived up to the hype since, from what I've seen, although I did enjoy his performance the other night.
Seriously??? They were shocked, as were a majority of the viewers. I don't think that can be called favoritism.
James and Scotty are my two faves but Scotty makes me feel like a pervy old woman b/c I think he's just too darn cute. Lauren hasn't impressed me at all and I am SO sick of hearing Hailey sing like Miley Cyrus talks!!! YUCK!!!
My favorite is Casey Abrams, although I also like Haley and James. Jacob is also kinda cool, although I've lost respect for him after his comment before performing "Man in the Mirror".
Pia should NOT have gone home. I'm so pissed about that. She wasn't my favorite, but she should've stayed over Stephano. Stephano is so generic.
Pia should NOT have gone home. I'm so pissed about that. She wasn't my favorite, but she should've stayed over Stephano. Stephano is so generic.
Yes, seriously.
The rules are, if you get the least amount of votes, you go home. Sure, it was shocking (especially since that even though I didn't care for Pia at all I do agree that others should have gone home before her) but to have Steven saying "this is bullshit" and Jennifer practically in tears is, I think, inappropriate. Just my opinion, Darlin'.
Last edited by a moderator:
Hmmm. And you've watched previous seasons, I presume, right??? It happens every season. Everyone is titled to their opinion...I just respectfully disagree.Yes, seriously.
Yes, I have watched prior seasons...and I don't remember ever seeing such a display as that - but it's entirely possible that I'm developing Alzheimer's.
To be fair, though, maybe it's partly because I'm really annoyed at the judges in general this season. I had such high hopes. I love me some Steven Tyler, but every single contestant's performance is not "just beautiful" every single time they sing. And Jennifer can't say anything negative either. Randy has become the "mean" judge (for lack of a better term), and even he rarely has anything negative to say. Don't get me wrong, I'm not wanting them to trash the contestants. . .but some honest constructive criticism would be nice for a change.
To be fair, though, maybe it's partly because I'm really annoyed at the judges in general this season. I had such high hopes. I love me some Steven Tyler, but every single contestant's performance is not "just beautiful" every single time they sing. And Jennifer can't say anything negative either. Randy has become the "mean" judge (for lack of a better term), and even he rarely has anything negative to say. Don't get me wrong, I'm not wanting them to trash the contestants. . .but some honest constructive criticism would be nice for a change.
Now THAT we can agree on. I do like the new judges, but I miss the honest criticism that Simon used to give. People gave him hell for being mean but he was almost always on point w/ his criticism.
I love the new judges.
Hailey SOOO NEEDs to go home!!
As for scotty... he sounds the same in all his music. I think hes great, but he can really only 'do' country.
Jacob lusk- i just dont like. His voice is good, but when he does his little thing with his voice its annoying.
HONESTLY, with pia, i think alot of the girls were jealous at how hot she was, so they didnt vote for her. LOL She is pretty hot and her voice was amazing!
I dont really like paul. He always looks drunk or drugged up.
And yes, I dont think casey has lived up to his auditions, but I saw alittle more of him last week. He played the bass and did great!
Hailey SOOO NEEDs to go home!!
As for scotty... he sounds the same in all his music. I think hes great, but he can really only 'do' country.
Jacob lusk- i just dont like. His voice is good, but when he does his little thing with his voice its annoying.
HONESTLY, with pia, i think alot of the girls were jealous at how hot she was, so they didnt vote for her. LOL She is pretty hot and her voice was amazing!
I dont really like paul. He always looks drunk or drugged up.
And yes, I dont think casey has lived up to his auditions, but I saw alittle more of him last week. He played the bass and did great!
I have watched very little this season.
A couple of years ago I saw every show.
I don't like the new judges, I don't like the voting system and I don't like the one judges save.
Simply......I don't like it all now. And when Simons other show gets launched, good bye AI.
A couple of years ago I saw every show.
I don't like the new judges, I don't like the voting system and I don't like the one judges save.
Simply......I don't like it all now. And when Simons other show gets launched, good bye AI.
AmericanIdle
New Member
Have you guys heard that Lady Gaga is going to be on the show next week? What do you guys think?
79,550Threads
2,190,511Messages
5,003Members