A question on God and Indian giving.

[Greatest I am]

A question on God and Indian giving.

You are given a gift, use it for a time, and then the one who gave you that gift takes it back without your permission or consent.

In other words, showing himself to be an Indian giver.

Would you call that a sin?
I call it a form of lying.

The giver is in effect saying, I am giving you this gift, when in reality, he is not, as demonstrated by his taking it back or away from you.
If not a lie, is that a sin and what is the sin called?

God himself in scriptures seems to do this regularly as he kills those he supposedly loves and takes away the free will gift he supposedly gave them. Their free will was obviously to live.

Is God an Indian giver?

Regards
DL

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lt2KNmB69EM&feature=related

 

[BornReady]

I don't share your belief God gave me life. My parents gave me life. My grandparents gave them life. And, not that it really matters, but it goes all the way back to some bacteria the best we can tell. So if God takes my life then he's taking something my parents gave me. Cool song though.

 

[Greatest I am]

I don't share your belief God gave me life. My parents gave me life. My grandparents gave them life. And, not that it really matters, but it goes all the way back to some bacteria the best we can tell. So if God takes my life then he's taking something my parents gave me. Cool song though.

Thanks.

It happens though that I too do not believe that God gave man anything.
Imaginary constructs are just that and anything they give would be just as imaginary.

Regards
DL